QuestionBrilliant! Thank you so much, that was really well done and the land analysis was brilliant! If it's not too much trouble, and if you don't mind analyzing such an ambiguous and loosely defined master class, could ya do the same for a Muse of Time?? Answer

Thank you for the compliment. It was quite exciting for us to receive an ask, and we’re glad to have helped you out. Happy Halloween.

image



Powers: CA


The Muse and the Lord are the two Master Classes, the most passive and most active (respectively) out of all the classes, and are extremely rare titles (only one character has ever had the title of Muse in the webcomic, and sadly, she’s dead. Her brother might still be alive, but the Lord of Time doesn’t talk much about his abilities). As such, there is very little known about the Master Classes. But I will, all the same, try to relate to you what I can.
They are hypothesized to Embody their Aspects, and, as such, are hypothesized to have all the abilities of the classes that fit their descriptions as passive or active. For the Muse, that would mean they would have the Seer’s ability to Know, the Heir’s ability to Manipulate, the Sylph’s ability to Create, the Bard’s ability to Destroy, the Page’s ability to Exploit, and the Rogue’s ability to Steal. As I’m sure you’ve noticed, most of these classes have to do with other people and their ability to use their Aspect in conjunction to others. The Muse would Know their Aspect and generally give that knowledge to others to work out amongst themselves. They would be able to Manipulate their Aspect, but be controlled by its whims, and perhaps, in a way, inherit their Aspect. They would be able to Create their Aspect for others, and perhaps heal them using their Aspect. Just as similarly, they would be able to Destroy their Aspect by giving others the tools to do it for them (or something similar). They would be able to allow their teammates (or just other people in general) to Exploit their Aspect as a weapon, and, to reach higher levels of power, would be forced to depend on others (not a bad thing, perhaps a little time-consuming, but not bad). And finally, they would be able to Steal their Aspect and give the spoils of their efforts to their teammates or allies.Furthermore, even better, is that it may very well be impossible for either the Muse or the Lord to invert their Class and Aspect. They would suffer no risk for inversion, meaning that they would have no need for balance between the use of their abilities and the lack of use of their abilities.
So, now that we’ve figured all that out, how would a Muse of Time function? What would their powers be? This is going to be a very long post here on abilities.
Well, to start out with, in working as a Seer of Time, they are unbelievably useful. The abilities of a Seer of Time (to put it simply because this is going to be a long enough post already) are to find what they’re looking for information on throughout all of time. If they wanted to know what the future would hold and if there were any way to avoid it if necessary, they would be able to look for that information, and if it exists, they would be able to find it. As such, their abilities would allow the Muse to guide their teammates towards the best possible Alpha timeline.
As an Heir of Time, the Muse would be able to manipulate Time, while still being constrained by its rules. Imagine Time as a parental figure. You cannot stop this thing from happening, they say. You try it. It keeps you from doing it by creating another problem somewhere else that you need to fix. The Muse would inherit Time in a sense, but really, in this context, as soon as they “receive,” Time, they’d likely just give it away to someone else. Which leads us on to our next role.
As a Sylph of Time, the Muse would be able to create Time for others, and, speculatively, heal using Time (or just heal Time). To create Time for others, I think that the Muse would be able to impart a sort of time travel gift to her teammates and allies (likely by collecting the minutes that they receive as the Heir). That would buy them time. It would allow them to become stronger, more skilled. It would relate back to the Page ability that I’ll mention later: the Muse, by giving their allies Time, would allow them to weaponize it to make themselves stronger. It would give all of their teammates Time to exploit. The Muse would basically be able to make all of their teammates Knights of Time, if only for a short while. Again, incredibly useful, and unbelievably powerful. And to heal Time or heal using Time is similar to the ability mentioned not long ago in the Sylph of Space post. Time would be the one deciding what needs to be healed if the Sylph means to heal others. If Time doesn’t miss it (or, rather, won’t miss it), then a person can’t be healed. But if the idea of healing Time is what the Muse is after, they would know who or what needs to be in when and where in order to, say, undo a paradox and set a timeline right again, and therefore heal Time.
As a Bard of Time, the Muse would be able to destroy Time using others, and invite destruction through Time. Destroying through Time is fairly simple to imagine. It’s like how aging can destroy anything. But to be honest, if things were just that easy, that would make them a Prince. Say that a teammate is about to do something incredibly stupid, and the Muse doesn’t want them to do it. The Muse would be able to convince them (again, the voice is the most powerful weapon a Bard has) to either stop doing the thing, or, if that fails, convince them to do something else first, and have them waste their minutes as the Knight of Time (read: have someone else destroy Time), and then not give them that ability again until they can convince them that what they were doing was stupid.
As a Page of Time, the Muse would rely on others to learn to reach their full potential, and in doing so, become incredibly powerful, and allow others to exploit Time as a weapon. This relates back to the Sylph abilities. They would be able to allow their teammates to exploit Time more actively than they ever could. The Muse would be able to give them the abilities of a Knight of Time, making time their weapon and their tool.
And finally, as a Rogue of Time, the Muse would be able to steal Time from others, and give their teammates the power-ups that come as a result. They could easily steal Time from beings that are around them, perhaps steal minutes from their lives, and give them to their allies. They would be able to prolong someone’s life as long as there are beings from which they could steal Time from. Of course, this could mean more than just minutes of life. It could mean that they could use those minutes for time travel. Almost like a cell phone plan, in hindsight.
This all seems really, REALLY awesome, right? Well, it is. The Muse isn’t a Master class for nothing. But a Muse will be really busy during the session, and furthermore, the Muse will have to keep all of these Time-related shenanigans straight. It’s possible that the Muse might cause a lot of problems if they accidentally (or otherwise) create a problematic paradox. Will they know how to avoid it? Yes, they would. Would they be able to undo it if the need arises? Yes, they would. But not all damage can be undone, and its negative repercussions might harm a lot of people, including the Muse themselves.
Another facet of the Muse was explained by Yaldaboath. When meeting with Yaldaboath, there are two choices that are presented to the player. Lords presumably always pick the choice that would grant them the power to “destroy anything they want for as long as they want,” while Muses assumably always take the other choice that was offered: “to give up all ambition and accept one’s death in exchange for the promise that their sacrifice will benefit all who ever lived by ending a force of unfathomable evil and destruction.” In other words, they are promised that their sacrifice will stop the person who made the first choice. Although this power may only be relevant in one-person (or maybe two-person) sessions, this does have a huge link to the Muse’s rating as the most passive of classes. After all, if everything works out okay, Calliope’s sacrifice as the Muse of Space would work out to everyone’s advantage, as it means that she would stop Caliborn’s rampage, and the only thing she had to do was die.
These abilities would not place the Muse in the front lines. They would likely be behind the scenes, far out of reach of the enemy, where they can orchestrate a battle as it goes along. They would give pretty much everything to their teammates, give them a clear path to victory and try to clear out any brush that might accidentally get in their way. A leadership role might be a good one for a Muse of Time, given their propensity for directing their teammates towards the ultimate goal. If not a leader, then at the very least a tactician.
Altogether, the abilities of a Muse of Time can be summed up pretty easily:
With great power comes great responsibility.


Weapons: TC

Well, my guess as to what weapons someone that belongs to either of the master classes would wield some of the more powerful weapons, but with Muses having more unassuming weapons than Lords.  The main evidence for this would be Calliope’s wand/pistol being less threatening looking than Caliborn’s scepter/assault rifle.  However, despite the unassuming appearance of Calliope’s weapon, it is assumed to be more powerful than Caliborn’s, as he abandoned his own weapon in favor of his sister’s, which he used to double kill some ghosts (and which Hussie tried to use to presumably kill him).
As such, these seem to be the type of weapons that a Muse of Time would use:

  • Artkind: If it’s not baroque, don’t fix it.
  • Bookkind: You can read your foes like a book.
  • Cardkind: What do you mean this isn’t your card? Oh, well. I have all the time in the world to find it.
  • Dicekind: Snake eyes.
  • Glovekind: The gloves are off now… Well, technically, they’re on, but you get the point.
  • Penkind: Now you, too, can feel INKluded.
  • Pistolkind: Shoot to thrill…
  • Staffkind: Gambit’s got nothing on you.
  • Wandkind: Yer a wizard.


The top four out of these weapon types are Artkind, Bookkind, Cardkind, and Penkind.


Land and Quest: TC and CA

Okay. Last bit. And possibly the most challenging.
See, the Muse, as one of the Master Classes, might have a land that is different from the other classes. The only problem is none of us know. The only Master Class player whose session we’ve seen is Caliborn, and his session was a one-player session, which we already know to be automatically different from that of any other kind of session. So we have no clue what type of world the Muse or the Lord, when found in another type of session (one with other people), would have. But personally, TC and I tend to agree on a sort of headcanon world for the Lord or Muse of anything in any session that has other people:
It would be completely barren. Almost like the worlds in Jane’s, Jake’s, Dirk’s, and Roxy’s Void session, but with fewer enemies, and possibly with no life on it in the first place. There would be no consorts in the land for the Muse to investigate. There would be no puzzles to solve. Nothing, save for the Muse’s quest bed and the Scratch Device, a necessary component to all Time lands. We imagine that the Muse’s denizen would be Yaldaboath, but there’s no certainty for Muses. It would allow them to make the choice that all Muses are expected to make.
But what, then, is their quest? If they have no definition to their land, no consorts, and practically the only monster in their land being the Denizen whose only act would be to offer them to choice all Muses must face, what quest could there possibly be for them? Well, the only possible quest that I can think of is the one that reflects their abilities: everyone else’s.
That’s right. Their quest is to make sure that everyone else’s quests happen while the session is still ongoing. Before the Black King is defeated, their quest is to give everyone else enough time, to give them enough ability to complete their own quests, all the while preparing for the final battle with the Black King. They have to use their abilities to the fullest here. They have to be able to see what needs to be done to defeat the Black King, to secure their session, they have to be able to give both themselves and their teammates enough time, and they have to make sure nothing gets messed up along the way, and then simultaneously try to set things up so that their teammates can finish their quests, so that they can finish their own, and so they all may better from it.
So how, then, would one design the land of a Muse of Time? Well, you could use the parts of this land that we hypothesize to actually exist. A word to describe the world’s aesthetic could be something related to the barrenness of the land. The other word could be a word that relates to both the Aspect of the Muse and the aesthetic of the world. For example, the Muse of Time could have words like Endings, Termination, or Death in their Land’s full name, given how Time is viewed as an Aspect connected to endings (as compared to Space, which has connections to beginnings). They might just even have their own Aspect as their Aspect word. Again, Muses and Lords take what we know of the rules of creating things like lands and quests and turn them on their heads. Which is entirely why we imagine that Muses and Lords wouldn’t have a quest word for their lands. They’re in charge of managing others’ quests, and, if the time should come, making the choice to sacrifice their lives to stop a force of great evil.

Anonymous Asked
QuestionMight I ask your opinion on the Maid of Heart's roles/path/challenge? And some possible weapons? Answer

image

Roles, paths, and challenges: CA

Okay. Maid is the active counterpart to the passive Sylph class, both of which create their Aspect. Maids are hypothesized to be an exclusively female class, but, again, anything is possible with god tiers. Maids, however, unlike Sylphs, actively create their Aspect, meaning that, first and foremost, the creation for their Aspect is for themselves. Take Aradia, as the Maid of Time, for instance. When she first was shown in god tier, her first act was to slow Jack down to a stop, thereby creating Time for herself. This simultaneously happened to create Time for her friends, but her first act was one of self-preservation. Not that this is a bad thing. To be honest, we were all kind of surprised by what was happening, and we didn’t expect Aradia’s dream self to already be god tier, so…
Anyway, Heart is the Aspect of self, emotion, and embodies the idea of a soul (hence how Dirk managed to attempt the ripping of Aranea’s soul out of her new body). A Maid of Heart would be a person who would go around creating either one of two things for themselves:
One: they could create emotions for themselves. This doesn’t mean IN themselves, although it could be that if it was really something they wanted. No, they would create emotions for their own purposes. If a Maid of Heart didn’t want to fight an army, they could create enough sympathy for themselves to either stop the army from fighting them and get it to fight themselves, or, if powerful enough, they could turn the entire army to their side. If they wanted to pump themselves and their team up to fight the Black King or something, they could create that fighting drive in themselves. They would be able to give themselves and others power through emotions.
Or, two, they could create Souls. I imagine it as an ability that would, at least most of the time, use an existing soul for a template, and it would create some slight physical form for the copy of the soul in question. Yes, a Maid of Heart would be able to copy souls to make clones of them. They would be able to create an army- an army with little in the way of physical form, meaning any blow they take would likely just be like passing through air, and any blow they make, would hit the soul. Any creature with a weak soul would be hurt really, really badly, practically destroyed by any blow they took from that army the Maid created. Even an enemy as potent as the Black King, given the existence, his being, if it was harmed every time the Maid’s army hit him, not even he would be able to stand up to it.
So as for roles, a Maid of Heart would likely be a more behind-the-scenes fighter. Allowing their army every chance to fight on their own, to heal them by recreating their template, to allow emotion and soul-crushing power to destroy their enemies for them. They would help their team by giving them high doses of fighting spirit. They’d be like one of those mage types from RPGs, providing buffs and making really powerful attacks.

As for paths…well, the Maid of Heart’s true path would have to involve embracing their emotions and their ability to manipulate others. This doesn’t mean that they’re going to utilize this ability. Hell, they could hate that they have it! They just have to recognize this ability of theirs, and recognize that using it is a good thing, providing they only use it in moderation. After all, their abilities are given to them for a reason, and that reason is to help them, believe it or not. Other paths involve using their powers too little (be this due to fear or some other factor), or using their powers too much (which would likely lead to class inversion, turning a Maid of Heart into a Bard of Mind).

As for challenges, I’m a bit confused as to what you mean. Do you mean quests? In which case I recommend a quest that would let them learn to use their foremost abilities (creating emotion and thereby manipulating people) better, maybe creating something that would stop a war between two factions of their consorts? This could be a speech, a song, a monument, really just anything that would help them stop whatever destruction is happening in their world.   A grander, overarching mission for all Maids would be to learn how to support their friends with their aspect, as support is the main purpose of both the Maid and their passive counterpart, the Sylph.
If you’re talking about personal problems, however, things like overcoming doubt or fear or such, I would say it would depend heavily on the Maid of Heart themselves. Some Maids of Heart might hate their ability to create emotions in people, or might not understand it, leading to them not knowing how to use their abilities when the time comes. Other Maids of Heart may be too eager to use their abilities, which might drive those on the tail end of their skills insane (as rapid and uncontrollable and unexplainable changes in mood sometimes can), destroying their thoughts, thereby turning the Maid of Heart into a Bard of Mind, with negative connotations for the Maid in question. I mean, just take a look at Jane, the Maid of Life, inverted by Her Imperious Condescension’s mind control tricks, forced into a Bard of Doom’s role. It results in her threatening Jake with rape (a result of her romantic feelings for Jake mixed with her frustration towards him and her just general anger), killing Karkat just to bring him back to life again (more anger with a mix of proving herself), and doing a ton of other pretty horrible stuff.

So, my altogether opinion of the Maid of Heart is that they would be a useful teammate, and have the makings of a pretty good grounding member for the team as an excellent communicator. All it would take is a bit of understanding their abilities.


Weapons: TC

The pattern for the most well known Maids’ weapons is that it is related to something that they are interested in.  Jane enjoys cooking and baking, so she uses a spoon/fork as a weapon.  Aradia enjoys archaeology, so she uses a whip like Indiana Jones.  Porrim supposedly used Kanaya’s chainsawkind specibus as well, showing her interest in fashion (it turns into lipstick!).  As for Heart players, they tend to use melee weapons that also reflect their interests, with Dirk’s anime and Nepeta’s roleplaying/cat theme (Theirs are based on slashing attacks, but I’ll cut you a break).  Seeing as I do not know what you are interested in, I will mostly use the Heart player pattern as a reference and make occasional guesses for your interests.
As such, the following would be suitable weapons:

  • Artkind: That’s why it’s called painting.
  • Bladekind: Always an option, especially if your interests are anime.
  • Bookkind: Interested in reading?  Why not destroy your foes with LITERATURE!!!
  • Chainkind: Anyone who shops at Hot Topic tends to have many weapons for this strife specibus.
  • Chainsawkind: Like chainkind, only sharper.
  • Clawkind: Ooh, shiny.
  • Entertainmentkind: Are you not entertained?
  • Fankind: I could say some cliche like “I’m your biggest fan”, but even I’m not that horrible.
  • Forkkind: Stick a fork in it.
  • Instrumentkind: The hills are alive…
  • Keykind: The fastest way to unlock a person’s heart?  Stab a key in their chest, of course!
  • Knifekind: One of our most over-recommended strife specibi, back with a vengeance.
  • Needlekind: Thankfully, there’s no need to thread these bad boys.
  • Penkind: Its name is Anaklusmos. For all you non-demigods out there, that means Riptide.
  • Pubkind: For all you alcohollics out there.  *Alcoholics.
  • Puppetkind: If you really feel you must.
  • Sciencekind: Blind them with science.  No, really, like stick a scalpel in their eye or something.
  • Scissorkind: Make sure someone prototypes paper.
  • Signkind: You said stop, now make sure they hear you.
  • Soundkind: …with the sound of music.
  • Sportskind: Touchdown, or whatever.  It matters little to me.
  • Staffkind: YOU SHALL NOT PASS!!!
  • Toykind: No more playing around.  (Yes, I know my puns are awful)
  • Wandkind: Expelliarmus!
  • Yoyokind: You’ll always bounce back.
QuestionHey, can you do Knight of Breath for me? Thank you so much! :) oh also would the Land of Pillows and Streetlights be a valid Land? Answer

Certainly. It’s great to receive an ask.

image

Powers: CA

Alright. So, as I mentioned last post (the one about Knights of Doom), the Knight is the active counterpart to the Page class, and they both fall into the Exploit classification, meaning they exploit their Aspect, either for themselves or others. Knights learn, by themselves, to reach their full potential, and that takes a little bit of soul searching or whatever, but in the end, they turn out okay. Anyway, while the Page may learn from others to reach their full potential, and they may end up more powerful as a result of it, whatever skills the Pages have, by the time they reach them, the Knights already know their powers inside and out, and they know how to do a lot more with them. But it’s not like it’s a competition.
So, combine the Class and the Aspect, and what do we get? We get a one-person army who has the wind fight for them. Breath is the Aspect of freedom and of, well, wind. That means that the Knight’s ability to keep moving, to remain as free as, well, wind, proves to their advantage. It, like so many other things for a Knight, can be used as a weapon. They can position themselves advantageously, and when the going gets tough in one spot, they know that to remain tough, they’ve got to get going. One of their greatest assets in battle is their ability to dodge and get themselves far away from their enemies, if necessary. They can’t be caught. And if they can’t be caught, then their attacks can keep landing.
Now, if we’re going to be going for more “the windy thing,” of the Aspect, then, yes, a Knight of Breath would essentially be able to airbend (in the case that you or anyone who reads this in the future has no idea what I’m referencing, it’s just a one-word term for controlling the air), and, in turn, weaponize the air. They might be able to suffocate their opponents, or blow them around in a tempest. Combine that exploitation of the winds and a Breath player’s lack of tether to much of anything (as per usual for Breath players, having freedom), and you might have a flying Knight on your hands. My thoughts on this flying ability pretty much sum up my thoughts on the Knight of Breath in total: Incredibly useful, potentially dangerous, but very awesome.
Now, I’m pretty sure I mentioned this before with the Knight of Doom post, but be aware that Knights tend to embody whatever Aspect is lacking from their session. Now in a Knight of Breath’s session, that might mean many things. It could mean that the gates that allow the player to teleport easily are really (and I do mean REALLY) hard to reach, or maybe just don’t exist at all. It could mean that, in the Knight’s world, or in everyone’s worlds in the session, there’s just a lack of enemies who supply enough grist to create what is necessary to reach the gates. A lack of freedom could easily be stifling for a session, and might even turn dangerous. The Knight would have to really embody their Class’ nomenclature and help everyone in their team out to do what needs to be done for their session, be it flying their teammates to their gates (once the Knight realizes their abilities, and maybe even reaches god tier), or supplying them with enough grist to get things moving. Good luck.


Weapons: TC

While we weren’t sure if you wanted a weapon analysis, we figured we’d throw one in for free!
As mentioned in the Knight of Doom analysis, the pattern for all currently revealed Knights’ weapons are bladed ones.  As for the Breath aspect, a common trait in its weapons is that they all have long reach, like John’s hammer and Tavros’s and Rufioh’s lances.  As such, the following weapons sound suitable for a Knight of Breath:

  • Axekind: You may not have a bow, but you have this axe.
  • Bladekind: Oh, yeah, you also have some of these swords.
  • Boomerangkind: Use a bladed boomerang.  The wooden ones are a huge stereotype.
  • Cardkind: Was this your card?  Yes.  Yes it was.
  • Knifekind: You wanna know how I got these scars?
  • Ninjakind: Go ninja, go ninja, go.
  • Polearmkind: I support the right to pole arms.
  • Scythekind: Seasons don’t fear the reaper, but they totally should.
  • Spearkind: First time using this one.  But it works.
  • Umbrellakind: I have this if only for things like the Barber’s best friend.



Land and Quest: TC and CA

Alright.The Land of Pillows and Streetlamps.
We like where you were going with this. It’s quite an interesting decor idea in our mind. Pardon us if we take a little creativity with this.
There’s a city. Sort of. I mean, how much of a city can consorts really make? Anyway, in this city, there are tall, and I mean REALLY tall, streetlamps, far beyond the reach of the Knight (and most of the consorts for that matter, so it’s a bit of a surprise that they were made). They were snuffed out some time ago, perhaps blown out by a denizen or another beast, or perhaps some sort of physical phenomenon (like a huge gust of wind), and since then, there were never any lights to protect the streets. The Knight’s quest is to learn to take advantage of their newfound mobility to light the streetlamps.
As far as I know, the quest word is good, and it also gives a feel to the land, so that’s all done. The only remaining problem is the Aspect word, and we’re not too sure “Pillows,” fits the bill. To be honest, it sounds a bit more like a Heart word than much of anything else.
Heart lands tend to reflect their players: soft, inviting, and, on average, not very intimidating (be this in looks or sounds). Pillows follow this trend, being soft and inviting, but we can see what you were looking to do with the idea. So a word or object that retains the Breath identity and is pillow-like. This could be Clouds, Fog, Mist, Cumulus, Heap, Stratocumulus, Mammatocumulus, etc. There are a lot of clouds that look like pillows and might be able to suit your purpose.
Hope we helped you.